• Indiana Edition •



Old Whitley Jail - Real Columbia City Haunted Place

  • East Market St.
  • Columbia City, IN
Average Review
  (1 review)
Listing Categories
Open To Public
NOT Open to Public
Share Your Experiences
This old jail was built in 1875 and is rumored to be haunted by an alcoholic bully, Charles Butler, who shot his wife in 1883. After the shooting, he was jailed here but escaped along with four other prisoners when Sheriff Frank Allwein was out. Butler was caught by the Sheriff shortly after when he was passed out in a bar. Once he was found he was tried and sentenced to hang, but his hanging did not go as planned. There were difficulties with the gallows, which lead Butler to be strangled for about 10 minutes before he died. His ghost is said to be electrically charged and has been blamed for cameras not working and batteries draining. There have been reports of display costumes moving on their own, footsteps, voices and laughter coming from the corner of a room. Also known to haunt the jail is an unknown female and Sheriff Allwein as well.
Nearby Real Haunts

Recently Shared Experiences & Comments

Share Your Experiences
  • Paranormal Investigation

    I have been to the haunted jail attraction. We have a group of paranormal investigators. We are based out of fort wayne. We were wondering if there was anyway we could get into the Old Jail to do an investigation. My name is joe and our groups name is Ghost Whispers paranormal. Please get back with me thank you.

    Posted 8/9/20

    Was this review helpful? YES NO

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful

Share Your Experience or Comments - Old Whitley Jail
  • Click to rate
  • Do not use all capital letters. No profanity.
  • Tell Us About Your Experience(s) at Old Whitley Jail. Be specific.
  • Administrative use only. Will NOT be displayed
  • Did You Have a Paranormal Experience?
  • Have You Been To This Haunt?

  • Would you recommended to a friend?
Real Haunt Listing Info

Visitors to this page: 729
Last edit to this listing: 3/25/2016 (2376 days ago)

Disclaimer: Indiana Haunted Houses does not endorse or support trespassing to visit real haunts. Before you visit ANY local real haunt, make sure to acquire the appropriate permits and/or permissions, and be respectful of privately owned properties. Countless Haunt Hunters have been arrested, ticketed, and reprimanded by the authorities for trespassing. To avoid this, be sure to get in touch with the property owners before visiting a haunt, and respect their hours of operation, local regulations, and rules for visiting at all times. Happy haunting!
All information on this page was submitted to Indiana Haunted Houses and was believed to be accurate at the time it was posted. Please report any inaccuracies here.